MENSIGHT Magazine

 

 

     MENSIGHT: The Journal of Conscious Masculinity
    On-line Magazine of TheMensCenter.com
      A Service of the Men's Resource Network, Inc
     Now with over 500 Pages of male positive content

VISION | MISSION | INTROSPECTION | COMPASSION | LEARNING | HEALTH | GROWTH | JUSTICE | EQUALITY
 
 


Home
Bookstore
Archive
Our Sponsors
The Men's Center
Free Newsletter

Click picture to take survey

Sponsored by
The Men's Resource Network, Inc.
Read about the survey

 

 

DOMESTIC ABUSE HELPLINE FOR MEN
1-888-7HELPLINE

HELP MENSIGHT
STAY ONLINE


All donations to The Men's Resource Network, Inc. are tax deductable.
 

Shopping on
 MENSIGHT



CLICK TO BUY
________________
Visit our Men's Issues
BOOKSTORE

 

 

MENSIGHT Magazine relies on 1&1, the World's #1 Web Host

 

SEARCH MENSIGHT | THE MEN'S CENTER | DONOR LIST | TRANSLATE | MEN'S CHAT

MEN'S ISSUES DISCUSSION BOARD

...
Click here to add this ticker  to your website

Book-of-the-Month... AUGUST 2006

Marked in Your Flesh:
Circumcision from Ancient Judea to Modern America

By Leonard B. Glick © 2006

Why do American physicians, unlike those in any other country but Israel, circumcise more than half of all newborn boys? How did an ancient sacrificial rite created by temple priests attain its current status as a routine American medical procedure? Leonard B. Glick answers these questions by tracing the history of infant circumcision from its origins in ancient Judea, through centuries of Christian condemnation and Jewish defense, to its current role in American culture and medical practice. A chapter of the book of Genesis, composed by priests around 500 BCE, says that God made a covenant with Abraham, promising him a glorious posterity on condition that he and all his male descendants be circumcised. Eventually the practice of infant male circumcision would become a key element in the separation between Judaism and Christianity. While Christians rejected circumcision as spiritually irrelevant, Jews held unwaveringly to the belief that being a Jewish male meant being physically circumcised. The situation changed dramatically in the nineteenth century, Glick shows, when progressive German Jews argued that ritual circumcision was anachronistic and inappropriate for members of a modern society. Some German-Jewish physicians declared that the surgery itself was so dangerous that it should be either reformed or eliminated. At the same time, however, British and American physicians began claiming that, despite the acknowledged dangers, circumcision cured all sorts of afflictions and protected against cancer and genital infections. Although support for circumcision eventually declined sharply in England, in America it has endured with remarkable tenacity. Glick shows that Jewish American physicians have been especially vocal and influential champions of the practice. Informed medical opinion is still divided, but most physicians now agree that circumcision confers no significant medical benefits; yet the practice is still routine in most American hospitals. At the same time, determined opposition has grown among those who recognize its significant adverse effects and the ethical and legal implications of imposing reductive surgery on the genitals of non-consenting persons. Moreover, Jewish opponents maintain that this disfiguring practice makes no positive contribution to modern Jewish American life. Marked in Your Flesh offers a challenging perspective that will engage readers on all sides of this multifaceted controversy. BOOK DESCRIPTION

horizontal rule

"Marked in Your Flesh shines as the rarest of beasts-a book that is learned yet accessible, deeply serious yet profoundly entertaining. Glick writes with one eye carefully checking footnotes while the other eye compassionately keeps watch over the precious newborn babies that are his ultimate subject. This engagingly written book contains lessons applicable to all of us concerned with protecting human rights and human well-being against encroachment by cultural and social forces."--J. Steven Svoboda, Founder and Executive Director, Attorneys for the Rights of the Child

horizontal rule

BOOKS ABOUT CIRCUMCISION

 
OUR SPONSORS
Marty Nemko
500+ of his acclaimed career and men's articles are FREE
Michael Gurian
Co-founder of
The Gurian Institute
Author of

THE MINDS OF BOYS:
 Saving Our Sons From Falling Behind in School and Life
MEN TO MEN
A peer led men's
support group
**************
Morristown, NJ

How Do I Become a
Corporate Sponsor?

Columns, Articles and Men's Issues News...

MEN'S NEWS TICKER © 2000 - Disable pop-up blocker
and click on headline for story details

...

MENSIGHT SPECIAL ISSUE ON
 MALE CIRCUMCISION

CIRCUMCISION ARTICLES

Article... by Ryan McAllister, Ph.D and Dan Sisan, Ph.D
C
ircumcision: Health, Sexism, and Human Rights
Circumcision may not be something you’ve thought about before, but it might be one of the most important decisions made for our children today. It is also a decision that illustrates how we perceive and care for our boy children differently than our girl children. 
Go to Article

horizontal rule

Article... by J. Steven Svoboda, Gregory J. Boyle, and Christopher P. Price
Circumcision of Boys: A Serious Male Health Problem...
Circumcision does not constitute genuine medical treatment.  It violates criminal law, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and also human rights. The health implications are graver than is generally realised, despite clear medical evidence of adverse effects from the pain, significant complications, psychological harm and inevitable prejudice to genital function. There are no clearly demonstrable medical benefits.  The law, the medical profession, and society in general seems to have turned two blind eyes to this serious form of violence against males.
Go to Article

horizontal rule

Article... by R. S. Van Howe, J. S. Svoboda*, J. G. Dwyer, and C. P. Price
Involuntary Circumcision: The Legal Issues
Circumcision is the amputation of the prepuce from the rest of the penis, resulting in permanent alteration of the anatomy, histology, and function of the penis.[1,2] Recently legal scholars have challenged neonatal circumcision’s legality[3-7] and argued that it constitutes child abuse.[8,9] While this conjecture may seem outlandish to American physicians who tend to a population in which 70% to 90% of the males are circumcised neonatally, such claims have a strong foundation in legal precedent and medico-ethical standards that aim to protect the bodily integrity of persons.
Go to Article

horizontal rule

Article... by Kristen and Jeffery O'Hara
The effect of male circumcision on the sexual enjoyment of the female partner
Male circumcision, the most commonly performed surgery in the USA, removes 33 - 50% of the penile skin, as well as nearly all of the penile fine touch neuroreceptors. To date no study has investigated whether this dramatic alteration in the male genitalia affects the sexual pleasure experienced by the female partner or whether a woman can physically discern the difference between a penis with a foreskin. The impact that male circumcision has on the overall sexual experience for either partner is unknown.
Go to Article

horizontal rule

Article...
Unnecessary Circumcision
. By George Denniston MD, MDH. ... We now know that circumcision does not prevent masturbation, nor does masturbation lead to insanity.
Go to Article

horizontal rule

Article...
Infant Circumcision FAQ... from
Circumcision Information Resource homepage
What is circumcision? ... What are some reasons that circumcision is performed? Circumcision is primarily performed for cultural or religious reasons. ...
Go to Article

horizontal rule

REGULAR FEATURES

Guest Article... by Glenn Sacks and Mike McCormick
NOW at 40: Group’s Opposition to Shared Parenting
Contradicts Its Goal of Gender Equality
...
The National Organization for Women turned 40 this summer, and formally celebrated its anniversary at its national conference in July. NOW President Kim Gandy has proudly recounted her organization's successes in opening up opportunities for women, and says they are “never giving up the dream of full equality for all.”
Go to Article

horizontal rule

Men's Worklife... by Marty Nemko
Making the Most of Career Counselors and Coaches...
Many older people seem to derive pleasure mainly by reminiscing or by waiting for their children to call. That is a formula for unhappiness, for feeling your life is essentially over.
Go to Article

horizontal rule

COYOTE... monthly column by Dick Prosapio
Hope at Work...
O
ur plant life here in New Mexico is the very personification of "Hope". We are in a drought here and, for those of you who have the luxury of not experiencing that, it means that everything dies.
At least, that would be true anywhere else a drought would strike, like Kansas for example. But here it means everything waits. Everything with the wisdom brought about through experience that is.

Go to Article 

horizontal rule

THE NEW INTIMACY... monthly column by Judith Sherven, Ph.D. and James Sniechowski, Ph.D.
Dying A Fabulous Death . . . Is That Possible?...
T
hink about the reasons you’re glad to be alive.
Those everyday things that you may even take for granted: being able to walk, talk, see, hear, cook, garden, drive a car, dance at parties, eat a terrific meal and laugh with friends.
And then think about what it would be like to start losing most of those abilities.
 
Go to Article

horizontal rule

JEFF'S LIFE... monthly column by Jeff Stimpson
His Old Man and the Sea...

I can still see that beach in Maine. An old high school friend sat with Ned on the sand while Jill and I took turns with Alex in the surf. Alex would dash in and out, splashing up to his knees. I'd whirl him high above the foam, milky stuff, frothy and warm. He loves the ocean, we knew then. The following summer, we went to Coney Island, and without stopping Alex ran into the ocean with his clothes on.     
Go to Article

horizontal rule

DADS, DON'T FIX YOUR KIDS... monthly column by Mark Brandenburg, M.A
Fathers, Anger, and Heart Attacks...
My kids were dawdling, even though I'd asked them to get ready on two occasions. "Come on!" I yelled. "How many times do I have to say this?" As they picked up their pace and came down the stairs, my kids both gave me a "look."
Go to Article

horizontal rule

TOWARD MANHOOD... A book in progress by Larry Pesavento
Chapter 18... 
Good Work
I
ndigenous peoples believed that one's identity and life work were sacred gifts from the gods. They did not believe that these things were arbitrary. These people were not existentialists, like modern man, believing that they could create their own identities, or arbitrarily create a satisfying life direction. In humility they believed that their work was the result of their calling. At the same time, they believed that their work was their identity playing out in their lives. They believed their work continued the work of a higher power, like the Force, if they kept themselves in harmony with that power. To them, one's work was intricately connected to one's spiritual path.
Read Chapter

 Men's Book Reviews by J. Steven Svoboda

LATEST REVIEWS

horizontal rule

REVIEW: Straight Talk for Men about Marriage: What Men Need to Know About Marriage (And What Women Need to Know About Men)
By Martin G. Friedman ©2006
The author has put together an appealingly presented, male-friendly guide to improving the quality of our marriages. As Friedman is the first to point out, this isn’t exactly rocket science. We need to learn to do the basics. A marriage is a path to learning about ourselves. Projecting our discontent onto our spouse doesn’t do either of us any favors.
READ FULL REVIEW
PURCHASE

REVIEW: Self-Made Man: One Woman’s Journey into Manhood and Back Again
By Norah Vincent
Norah Vincent has produced a new book whose simple underlying concept nevertheless seems to possess all the potential power of, say, John Howard Griffin’s classic Black Like Me, in which the Caucasian author masqueraded as a black man and was astonished at the depths of the discrimination and barriers he discovered.  Author Vincent tries to do the same thing for gender, dressing in drag as “Ned” and entering various supposed male bastions to report on what she discovers.

READ FULL REVIEW

PURCHASE

REVIEW: The Smart Couple’s Guide to the Wedding of Your Dreams:
Planning Together for Less Stress and More Joy

By By Judith Sherven and James Sniechowski
Judith Sherven and James Sniechowski, husband-and-wife psychologists and authors of three books previously reviewed by me in these pages (The New Intimacy, Opening to Love 365 Days a Year, and Be Loved for Who You Really Are) have just published a new book on their favorite topic, love and marriage. In a literal sense, The Smart Couple’s Guide to the Wedding of Your Dreams covers a narrower subject than any of their three previous books.  But actually, predictably enough given the authors’ excellent writing skills and tireless, creative devotion to promoting passion, their latest offering manages to transcend the limits of the genre of wedding guides.  Not seeing a book that went beyond the technicalities of wedding planning and touched the spirit of the event, they took the plunge and wrote it!
READ FULL REVIEW

PURCHASE

REVIEW: Partnering: A New Kind of Relationship
By Hal Stone and Sidra Stone © 2006
Hal and Sidra Stone are, like Judith Sherven and James Sniechowski (whose latest book is reviewed elsewhere in this issue) a husband-and-wife psychologist team who have written a number of books and who travel the world giving workshops on their techniques for improving one’s life and relationships.  Partnering does not represent a stunning advance on the authors’ previous work but it does expand, in the specific context of relationships, on the work they have helped pioneer in exploring the multiple selves each of us contains through the voice dialogue technique.
READ FULL REVIEW
PURCHASE

REVIEW: The Prodigal Father: A True Story of Tragedy, Survival, and Reconciliation in an American Family.
By Jon DuPre.
Jon DuPre’s achievement with “The Prodigal Father” is stupefying. What this correspondent for Fox Network News has done is so simple: He has told the story of his family of origin, consisting of two brothers, himself, and his mother and father. As a novel, the book would fail. For one thing, the plot would be utterly unbelievable! But “The Prodigal Father” is billed as an “autobiography,” and written with loving detail and self-revelation so honest and so deep that took my breath away. As such, it is utterly compelling and simultaneously completely credible.
READ FULL REVIEW
PURCHASE

REVIEW: Gendercide and Genocide
Edited by Adam Jones © 2006
Apart from the rarest exceptions (such as the not-to-be-missed “
Female ‘Circumcision’ in Africa: Culture, Controversy, and Change,” Edited by Bettina Shell-Duncan and Ylva Hernlund), edited volumes tend to be hit-and-miss affairs. It’s hard enough simply to find an appropriate topic, to accumulate contributions that are varied enough to provide interest but not so different that they work at cross-purposes, and to publish the work. Maintaining a razor-like focus as can easily be done with an individually authored book by definition becomes almost impossible with an edited volume.
READ FULL REVIEW
PURCHASE

Archive of All Reviews & Interviews... by J. Steven Svoboda.

horizontal rule

Guest Books

MILITARY HONOR ROLL... Pay tribute to the Veterans or Active Duty military in your life on our perpetual Military Honor Roll page
Go to Military Honor Roll

FATHERS HONOR ROLL... Pay tribute to your father (grandfather, great grandfather, etc.) on our perpetual Fathers Honor Roll page
Go to Fathers Honor Roll

horizontal rule

VISIT

horizontal rule

MENSIGHT Magazine is another free service of The Men's Resource Network, Inc. (MRN). It has grown out of the response that we have received from articles posted on TheMensCenter.com (TMC), our official web-site. The first issue went on-line on May 1, 2000. (Archive)

MENSIGHT is dedicated to publishing diverse articles for and about men. We believe that there are valuable lessons to be learned from the advocates of all the various men's issues.

MENSIGHT will publish articles, stories and information that will be welcomed by many and controversial to others. We offer the magazine for your edification but you are free to disagree or reject what you do not like. Be advised that we do not necessarily agree with every position that is expressed here.

We hope that you will be entertained, informed, educated, stimulated, and/or motivated by what you read here. We seek to empower men to be the authority of their own lives. We do not seek to tell men what to think or feel.

horizontal rule

 

 
About | Archive | Bookstore | Library
Copyright © 2000-2006 The Men's Resource Network, Inc. All rights reserved